The DHM first read The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to the Equuschick and me when we were very young. Because of that, I now have wonderful memories of snuggling under the blanket and hearing about the adventures of the Pevensie children. Since that time, I have read the Narnia books repeatedly. Our family has gone through 2 1/2 sets of them, they are used (and abused) so frequently. Any hardcover copies found at library booksales are snatched up. Come to think of it, paperback copies get picked up too. Jane Austen's books, the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the Narnia books are all ones that we are pleased to have extra copies of floating about. You never know when you might want to read one, it needs to be easily accessible, and you want to be sure that you have a copy for the sister that will (of course) decide she also wants to re-read it at the same time you do. Some of the girls here do not play fair -- rather than letting you finish the book before starting on it, which is only cricket, they begin reading it at moments when you are cleaning the kitchen and refuse to hand it over when you're finished.
Not that I'm bitter about it. Oh, no.
Before our vacation to DC, The DHM picked up something quite exciting, really. She got The Horse and His Boy, unabridged, read aloud on cassette tape by Alex Jennings. Jennings is a fine British actor, and any Narnia production worth its salt must be unabridged, so we were all very happy.
We were even happier when JennyAnyDots found The Magician's Nephew, from the same "set" as the Jennings one, narrated by Kenneth Branagh. We are great fans of Branagh, and this recording increased our admiration. His vocal abilities, only mildly apparent in films like Much Ado about Nothing, were strong for this book. Aslan was majestic, the elephant was petty, the bears slow...everything was perfect. :-)
We are on a roll now. I have checked out Michael York's recording of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. It has been amusing to listen to this on tape, as I know many parts of it so well I just end up speaking along with York. "jollification for weeks on end..." is a phrase that sticks in my mind. Maybe that was the first time I'd heard the word "jollification," or maybe it just paints such a delightful word picture you can't help but remember it.
Our next treat? We can only hope the library has Jeremy Northam's recording of The Silver Chair. We are also fans of Jeremy Northam (do you detect a trend here? British actor, we are fans) and can't imagine anyone more suitable for this book.
Does it bother you girls the way it bothers me that the new editions of the Narnia books have put them into chronological order instead of publication order? It just drives me nuts to think that if I don't pay close attention when they get old enough, my children could read the books in the wrong order and learn the identity of the professor and the significance of his past before it makes sense in the story. (Along with other screwups entailed in reading them in this order.)
ReplyDeleteWhat are the publishers thinking??
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteOh boy! The squirrel public library has four different ones in this series: The Horse And His Boy, The Last Battle, The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe, and The Silver Chair. And Patrick Stewart does The Last Battle! Mama Squirrel would love to check these out, except that Ponytails hasn't been read any of them yet--would that be missing out on something? Did you let your First Years listen in to the audio books, or had they already heard them?
ReplyDeleteJdavidb, Lewis actually agreed that it would be better for them to be read in chronological order!
ReplyDeleteMamaSquirrel:
ReplyDeleteSince they are unabridged versions, the First Years listened to them. I don't think Ponytails would be missing out on much unless you wanted to make these an actual family read aloud.
I found a set where Derek Jacobi did the Last Battle too, and that was also exciting! Patrick Stewart is also a nice prospect.
I know that C.S. Lewis thought it was fine for the books to be read in chronological order (and even recommended it), but I agree with David. It was so much lovlier to discover who the professor was and why the wardrobe worked *after* reading the LW&W.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Lewis was wrong. (Who says an author must know best about this own books?) It is more rewarding to read them in publication order.
ReplyDelete